Helloooo restaurateur!!!
No, no, I have not lost my ability to write correct grammar. I am, however, at a complete loss for words with the amount of information my brain has been fathoming since Sunday, and I am all set to spill it here. (Do not worry, I will not overwhelm you.)
Two things landed on my desk this week.
One is a line from a US analyst. The other is a number from our own festive data. They look unrelated at first, but together they explain why so many restaurants are busy and still wondering where the profit went.
What Did The Fast Food Giants Just Learn?
Peter Saleh, an analyst at U.S. Bancorp | BTIG, wrote that “the deep value war is over, and all have lost.”
Deep value is a fancy way of saying 50% off for everyone, all day, please come. Combos, buy one get one, flat discounts, every chain trying to be cheaper than the next. The result, he noted, was little to no extra traffic and weaker margins.
So what are the big chains doing now?
Domino’s says it is working on more targeted promotions, and William Blair’s Sharon Zackfia pointed out that Shake Shack used behaviour-based communications and targeted offers to drive frequency. (Source: Restaurant Dive, 22 October 2026)
Indian restaurateurs, you know this war well. It has been running on your Swiggy and Zomato dashboard for years, one “50% off up to ₹100” at a time.
Who Are You Really Offering This To?
A blanket discount is what you send when you do not know whom you are talking to. It lands on the regular who eats with you every Friday and on the guest who came once in 2022, and both get the identical offer.
A targeted offer is what you send when you know who is who. Regulars get one reason to come back, lapsed guests get another, and first-timers get a third. Which brings us to the tiny thing that makes all of this possible 👇
Why Do Festivals Make Restaurants Forget To Ask?
That is where the subject line comes in. “Hi, who dis” is exactly what your restaurant is asking every guest who walks out without leaving a number.
We went through our festive season data, from Navratri to New Year.
December was the busiest month on our platform, with restaurants taking 7.6% more orders a day than in a normal month. Full tables, long queues, everyone sweating happily.
In the same month, 16% more orders went out without a phone number than in a normal month.
In plain words, 16% more orders than usual went out with no contact number attached, and October and November were already about 11% higher. The busier it gets, the less anyone asks.
Why? Because nobody at a loaded counter is thinking about a database. The queue is long, the family of eight is debating dessert, the festive staff joined on Tuesday, and “May I have your number?” quietly leaves the building.
The numbers above come from our festive report, which also has ready-to-send messages you can copy and paste before your next rush 👇
How Do Missing Numbers Lead Back To Blanket Discounts?
Now that the report is saved (you did save it, right?), let me connect the dots. Remember those blanket discounts the US giants just gave up on?
They sit a lot closer to your December counter than you would think.
Picture it:
December sends you a crowd of new faces, which is your biggest chance to build a list of people you can actually talk to. A guest who leaves without sharing a number becomes a stranger again, and the only way left to reach a stranger is a blanket discount, tossed out in the hope that the right person sees it.
Meanwhile, here is what our data says about January. That is when customers come back to spend the points they have earned, with 5.2% more customers redeeming than in a normal month. You can only invite them back if you have their number.
So the chain runs like this. Without the number, you cannot target, and without targeting, you are left with blanket discounts, which are exactly what the US giants just admitted did not work.
Funny how a tiny question at the counter ends up deciding your whole marketing strategy, right?
What Should You Do Before December Hits?

Capture the number on every bill
Make it as automatic as asking “dine in or takeaway?” And please say it like a human. God knows how many times I have seen this exact line, “number please?”, delivered with the warmth of a customs officer at an airport.
Guests do not hand over a number to a stranger who sounds like they are stamping a passport. Give them a reason instead: “Share your number and get points on today’s bill” sounds like a gift, and it gets a very different answer.
Add one line to your festive team briefing
You are already briefing your team for the rush, so add the number ask to that same conversation. One sentence on what to say and why it matters is enough, and it saves you a month of strangers.
Split your list before you send anything
Tag your guests by visit count and last visit date, so regulars, lapsed guests and first-timers each get their own message. That one step is the whole difference between a targeted offer and a blanket blast.
Send December’s new faces a January nudge
Pick one campaign in mid-January for the customers who first walked in over Christmas, and remind them of the points they earned. Those points are a ready reason to return, and your December strangers become your January regulars.
Ready To Meet Your Guests Properly?
December is going to send you a crowd of strangers, whether you are ready or not. The only choice you have is whether they leave as strangers or as people you can invite back in January.
So this festive season, let your counter do the introductions. Ask for the number, say thank you, and by January you will know exactly who is who, with no “hi who dis” left to ask.
Until next week!
