×

Turn Restaurant Regulars into Subscription Members: A Complete Guide

turn-restaurant-regulars-into-paying-members
user Profile  | Last updated on:11 Jun 2025

Restaurant owners across India are raising their voices against rising Zomato and Swiggy commissions, and more importantly, the loss of control over customer data. In an industry where margins are tight and loyalty is everything, this lack of ownership feels like handing over your most valuable asset.

But while aggregator wars rage on, a quieter, more powerful movement is picking up steam: Restaurant Subscription.

This isn’t just a trend or a fancy gimmick. Restaurant subscriptions are giving control back to the restaurateurs. Think about it, you decide the pricing, you own the data, and you build direct, recurring relationships with your best guests. It’s like turning your regulars into members of an exclusive club, where they feel valued, and you build predictable revenue.

From Panera to Pret A Manger to local stars across India, subscriptions are reshaping the dining experience. And now, it’s your turn.

Why Restaurant Subscriptions Are Worth Your Attention?

The Shift from Loyalty Programs to Subscriptions

Traditional loyalty programs offer points. Subscriptions offer a relationship. More and more restaurants are shifting to subscriptions because they drive deeper engagement and long-term revenue. Instead of waiting for the customer to return, you’re giving them a reason to commit upfront. You must read: Restaurant Loyalty Program vs Membership

benifits-of-subscriptions-for-customers-and-restaurants

Benefits for Restaurants

  • Predictable revenue: Know how much you’re earning every month.
  • Customer retention: Keep guests coming back for more.
  • Operational planning: Manage staffing and inventory better with consistent footfall.

Also read: 12 Powerful Membership Program Benefits for Restaurants

Benefits for Customers

  • Value for money: Exclusive perks make the subscription feel like a steal.
  • Convenience: No need to track points or wait for rewards.
  • Exclusivity: Early access, limited menus, or member-only tables build FOMO.

Understanding Your Regulars

Who Are Your Regulars and Why Do They Matter?

Regulars are your most valuable customers. They bring in consistent revenue, cost less to retain, and are most likely to spread the word about your restaurant.

How to Identify Ideal Subscription Candidates Using Data

Use your POS or CRM system to pull:

use-your-crm-to-pull-data

This data helps you find customers who would benefit most from your restaurant subscription.

What Type of Customer Benefits Most?

  • Office-goers nearby who grab lunch daily
  • Coffee lovers who order a cappuccino every morning
  • Families who dine with you every weekend

Segmenting Your Audience

Break your audience down by:

  • Age: Young professionals vs. families
  • Location: Nearby residents vs. office crowds
  • Habits: Breakfast buyers, dinner diners, weekend brunchers
  • Preferences: Vegan eaters, dessert fans, cocktail lovers

Designing a Compelling Restaurant Subscription Model

Popular Types of Restaurant Subscription Programs

Prepaid Dining Credit Customers pay a fixed amount monthly and get bonus credit. For example, pay ₹1,000 and get ₹1,200 worth of dining.

Meal Tickets and Monthly Credits Offer 10 meals a month for a flat fee. This works well for quick-service or lunch-heavy outlets.

Curated Dining Experiences Create monthly tasting menus, chef’s tables, or surprise boxes for your members.

Unlimited Drinks or Menu Items Like Pret A Manger’s coffee subscription—think unlimited coffee, mocktails, or even starters.

Member-Only Events and Experiences Invite members to exclusive tasting nights, launch events, or cooking classes.

Setting Up Tiered Memberships

Offer Basic, Mid-Level, and Premium tiers:

tier-based-subscription-model
  • Basic: A few perks like discounted meals
  • Mid-Level: Extra value with member-only items or faster service
  • Premium: All-access passes, private bookings, and VIP events

How to Decide on Pricing and Benefits

  • Benchmark against your average ticket size
  • Ensure perceived value is always higher than price
  • Test with a pilot group of loyal customers

💡 Pro Tip: Reelo help you build and manage customized restaurant memberships effortlessly. Right from pricing and perks to targeting the right audience and tracking results. Whether you want to set up prepaid credits, exclusive rewards, or tiered programs, Reelo has your back.

25+ Creative Subscription & Membership Ideas

  • Coffee of the Day Pass
  • Unlimited Soup Bowl
  • Sunday Brunch Club
  • Takeaway Tuesdays
  • Dessert First Fridays
  • Family Feast Box
  • Kids Eat Free Pass
  • Monthly Wine Tasting Club
  • Chef’s Special Preview Night
  • Late-Night Biryani Plan
  • Work-from-Café Monthly Pass
  • Unlimited Chai Hour
  • Breakfast All-Month Pass
  • Momos Every Monday
  • Samosa Subscription
  • Weekly Thali Fix
  • Pizza Fridays for Members
  • Weekend Grill Nights
  • Dosa of the Day Plan
  • Seasonal Fruit Juice Club
  • Happy Hour Every Hour (Members Only)
  • DIY Cooking Kits Subscription
  • Meal-for-Two Plans
  • Midnight Snackers Club
  • Fast Lane Ordering (skip the queue)
  • BYOB Corkage-Free Nights (Members Only)

Brand Examples to Learn From

  • Panera Bread: Unlimited coffee for $11.99/month
  • Pret A Manger: Coffee subscription success led to global expansion
  • Taco Bell: Monthly Taco Lover’s Pass
  • El Lopo: Membership with social perks like wine nights and local artist meetups

Building Community Through Subscriptions

Creating Digital and Offline Communities

Use WhatsApp groups, private Instagram pages, or email newsletters to give members a sense of belonging. Share behind-the-scenes moments, new launches, and shoutouts.

Hosting Member-Only Events

Celebrate member milestones, host trivia nights, or bring in guest chefs. These events turn customers into ambassadors.

Do Subscriptions Build Belonging?

According to Reddit threads and Quora discussions, people stick to memberships that make them feel seen. A personalized birthday note or early access to a seasonal menu goes a long way.

Managing Restaurant Subscriptions Smoothly

Tools and Platforms That Can Help

Look into:

  • POS-integrated loyalty software
  • Subscription management platforms (e.g., Recharge, Stripe Billing)
  • WhatsApp or SMS tools for reminders and perks

Reelo makes this part a breeze. Its smart dashboard lets you track redemptions, customer visits, payment cycles, and even segment subscribers by behavior. It’s built with restaurant teams in mind.

Tracking Usage and Benefits

Monitor:

  • Redemption rates
  • Visit frequency of members vs. non-members
  • Upsell potential during subscription visits

Integrating with Existing Systems

Ensure your subscription works with your existing POS, CRM, and loyalty platform. The smoother the experience, the higher the retention.

Promoting Your Restaurant Subscription

How to Launch Effectively

  • Announce to regulars first
  • Offer a limited-time discount for early subscribers
  • Run a giveaway for referrals

Read about this in detail!

The Role of Personalization

Use customer data to promote the right subscription. Don’t pitch a cocktail plan to a teetotaler.

Who to Target First: Walk-Ins or Regulars?

Start with regulars. They already love your food. Use promotions to convert them before you expand to newer guests.

Using Coupons to Hook Subscribers

Give a one-time-use coupon to first-time users. If they redeem it and enjoy the experience, they’re likely to convert.

Measuring Success and Making It Better

Key Metrics to Track

restuarant-subscriptions-key-metrics-to-track

Feedback and Continuous Improvement

Send quick surveys. Ask:

  • Are you using the benefits?
  • What would make this more valuable?
  • Would you recommend this to a friend?

Common Questions from Restaurant Owners

Did Anyone Try Subscriptions? What Happened?

Yes! Many found that even 100 paying members at ₹1,000/month generated stable revenue and improved planning.

Biggest Challenges?

  • Tech integration
  • Keeping it simple
  • Ensuring consistent value

Handling Cancellations

Have a clear policy. Offer the option to pause instead of cancelling. Re-engage with surprise perks.

Keeping Subscribers Engaged

Fresh benefits, exclusive events, and regular check-ins are key.

What Can Go Wrong? (And How to Prevent It)

Common Pitfalls

  • Offering too many confusing benefits
  • Poor execution or redemption glitches
  • Overpromising, underdelivering

How to Avoid Them

  • Start small, test, and scale
  • Keep the offer clear and trackable
  • Use automation tools wherever possible

Click here to read about this in detail.

The Future of Restaurant Subscriptions

What’s Next?

The subscription model will become smarter and more tailored. Think AI-driven personalization, hyperlocal events, and app-based experiences.

Changing Customer Behavior

Consumers are subscribing to everything, from music to meals. Restaurants that adapt early will stay ahead of the curve.

Innovations to Watch

  • Dynamic pricing for high-demand slots
  • Community perks beyond the restaurant
  • Collaborations between multiple outlets

Conclusion: Your First Steps

Restaurant subscriptions aren’t just a trend. They’re a tool to build a deeper relationship with your most loyal customers.

Key Takeaways:

  • Use data to identify your regulars
  • Design offers that balance value and simplicity
  • Start small and iterate based on feedback

If you’ve been thinking about launching a restaurant subscription, now is the time. Platforms like Reelo make it easier than ever to design, automate, and scale your program, without getting stuck in tech complexity.

Schedule a free demo today and make your regulars stick for good.


About The Author

Priyalshri is a B2B SaaS content marketer who turns ideas into stories that stick. With a knack for simplifying the complex and making the simple unforgettable, she believes storytelling is the key to making marketing both entertaining and impactful.

sheet

Start with Customer Loyalty.
Stay for Limitless Growth!​

Start with a 14-day Free trial, explore yourself.

sheet

Discover more from Reelo

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading